Dom Robinson reviews
Titanic
THX Widescreen
Distributed by
Pioneer Entertainment Europe
Producers:
James Cameron and Jon Landau
Screenplay:
Music:
Cast:
Jack Dawson: Leonardo DiCaprio (The Man In The Iron Mask, Marvin's Room, Romeo And Juliet, This Boy's Life, Total Eclipse, What's Eating Gilbert Grape )
Rose Dewitt Bukater: Kate Winslet (Hamlet, Heavenly Creatures, Hideous Kinky, Jude, Sense And Sensibility, TV: "Casualty" )
Cal Hockley: Billy Zane (Dead Calm, Lake Consequence, Memphis Belle, Orlando, The Phantom, Sniper, Tombstone )
Holly Brown: Kathy Bates (Dolores Claiborne, Misery, Primary Colors, White Palace )
Ruth Dewitt Bukater: Frances Fisher (Attack Of The 50 Foot Woman, Female Perversions )
Captain Smith: Bernard Hill (The Bounty, Drowning By Numbers, Shirley Valentine, TV: "Boys From The Blackstuff", "Lipstick On Your Collar" )
Bruce Ismay: Jonathan Hyde (Bliss, Deadly Advice, Jumanji, Richie Rich )
Fabrizio: Danny Nucci
Old Rose: Gloria Stuart (The Invisible Man )
Spicer Lovejoy: David Warner (The Man In The Iron Mask, The Omen, Scream 2, Star Trek 5, Time Bandits, TV: "Star Trek: Next Generation" )
Thomas Andrews: Victor Garber (Hostile Advances - The Kerry Ellison Story )
Brock Lovett: Bill Paxton (Aliens, Apollo 13, The Evening Star, Near Dark, Tombstone, True Lies, Twister )
Lizzy Calvert: Suzy Amis (The Ballad Of Little Jo, Blown Away, Firestorm, The Usual Suspects )
Fifth Officer Lowe: Ioan Gruffudd (TV: "Hornblower" )
Titanic Orchestra: I Salonisti
Steerage Band: Gaelic Storm
Titanic
is James Cameron 's epic account of the night that the
R.M.S. Titanic went too fast on its maiden voyage and hit an iceberg, rupturing
the underside of the ship's head and letting enough water in to make it sink.
It's one of those films that doesn't really need its plot explaining as there
can't be many people on the planet who don't know that the ship didn't quite
make it to its destination, but rather took a diversion to the ocean bed.
In amongst the carnage, comes a tale of forbidden love and courage in the face
of disaster. Leonardo Di Caprio and Kate Winslet, who was nominated for an
Best Actress Oscar, as Jack and Rose, the young lovers separated by social
class yet destined to find each other on the "unsinkable" ship.
The film won eleven Oscars including Best Picture and Best Director and it's
easy to see why due to the grand scale of what's on show. When the ship starts
to go down, it's a special effects extravaganza from the huge reconstruction
of the vessel - a 90%-scaled model - right down to the mere breath of cold
air exhaled by cold and frightened passengers. The success of the film has
resulted in worldwide box office takings of over $1 billion and has spawned
two soundtrack albums featuring James Horner 's unsurpassable score and
music from the film including Celine Dion and "An Irish Party In Third
Class" .
It could have been a different story though. Originally budgeted at around
$120 million, delays and mounting problems forced production costs to spiral
in rocket-like fashion to way over $200 million. Soon after, Cameron was being
criticised beyond all comprehension and Hollywood critics reckoned the film
would sink at the box office like its namesake ship.
Thankfully, Cameron was proved right in the end. Cinemagoers and the rest of
the nation piled into the cinemas for over six months, a rare sight indeed.
In fact the only other film from recent times that has stayed in cinemas for
as long was the British hit, The Full Monty , but it's quite a different
thing though to get the average Joe to stampede to the cinema for a film over
three hours in length - as opposed to a 90-minute comedy - and as such Titanic
has become the biggest grossing film of all time to date.
A first-class film deserves a first-class cast and it gets it with the two
leads performed by rising star, sometimes dubbed as the new River
Phoenix , Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet , who is usually
found in low-budget films, but has been cast into the limelight with this film.
It hasn't gone to her head though and even at her recent wedding to James
Threapleton, assistant film director on the set of her forthcoming film
Hideous Kinky , there were no major amounts of security and the press
were allowed to take photos, unlike a recent Spice Girl wedding.
While Jack is, literally, the small fish in a big pool of rich people, the
rest of the cast includes Billy Zane as Rose's prospective but
destructive husband, Frances Fisher as Rose's mother, Bernard
Hill as the ship's captain, Jonathan Hyde as the ship's creator,
Bill Paxton as the leader of a crew interviewing Rose in the present
day trying to find out what exactly happened and Gloria Stuart as Rose
now, which gave her the nomination for the Best Supporting Actress Oscar.
There are a few pieces of artistic licence though such as the scene of the
captain going down with the ship, although apparently the real one didn't,
as well as occasional one liners: As one man walks climbs a staircase towards
the rear of the ship he recites Psalm 22. When he gets to "Yea, as I walk
through the valley of the shadow of death", Jack shouts, "Wanna walk a little
faster to that valley ?"
A stunning film deserves a stunning transfer and that's exactly what you get
here. In the cinema the film was breathtaking and at home, even on a 21"
television, the experience, for me, has as great an impact. The widescreen
framing is preserved here and it's the only way it can be watched. Although
the film was shot using the Super-35 technique, allowing non-SFX shots to
sometimes be shown with more picture at the top and/or bottom, while losing
some side picture information, word has it that the fullscreen version is as
bad as a standard pan-and-scan transfer.
Note that as the widescreen version has a ratio of 2.30:1 and that widescreen
televisions have a ratio of 16:9 (ie. 1.78:1 approx.), so you will still get
black bars on your widescreen television. This may seem obvious to may
laserdisc owners out there, but while a few people have asked me why this
happens - because one medium is wider than the other, so the old adage that you
can't fit a square peg in a round hole applies - the problem manifested itself
on BBC TV's Watchdog after an old man had more money than sense and
spent £1700 on such a TV without bothering to learn the difference in
ratios and complained when his Titanic video didn't fill the screen.
Watchdog went on to explain, badly, that there are six different film ratios -
when there are many more - and then showed the film on a widescreen TV but
using the 16:9-enhanced mode (on a non-enhanced video) thus squashing the
picture further and making everyone look fatter and accentuating the black bars
thus filling the screen with twice as much blackness.
The sound quality is superb as well. Not only the aforementioned score and
music, but the speakers will cry out as the ship rips apart. This PAL laserdisc
is only the second to carry the THX logo for approved picture and sound quality.
Plenty more discs will have been taken from a digital clone of a THX-approved
master such as Braveheart, Independence Day and Speed , but it
isn't cheap to include the logo on the cover.
There are 30 chapters throughout the film which isn't enough for a 189-minute
film and there is no trailer, but there wasn't one on the NTSC Laserdisc
either, the only thing you're missing out on being the Dolby Digital soundtrack.
This disc also comes in a gorgeous gatefold sleeve and the film is split across
four sides in CLV.
If I had any complaints it would be the low number of chapters and that fact
that the film suffers the U.S. problem of "PG-13"-itis, namely that the only
thing done to attain that rating was to include one unnecessary "f-word" in the
script.
Overall, this is my favourite film of the year and one of the best reasons to
buy a laserdisc player since Encore's release of "The Big Blue: Version
Longue" earlier this year. Rumours are abound, though, that James Cameron
will eventually release a director's cut containing 30 minutes extra footage,
a commentary track and a making-of documentary. Perhaps that will be the running
order on the DVD when Fox get around to the market outside Japan. Until then,
the only Titanic-esque DVD content appears on Carlton's A Night To
Remember .
For now though, this disc only has competition from the NTSC Laserdisc which
is more expensive at $50 and a widescreen video box-set costing even more
at £79.99 and contains the film, the script and the making-of documentary.
FILM : *****
PICTURE QUALITY : *****
SOUND QUALITY : *****
EXTRAS : 0
-------------------------------
OVERALL : ****
Review copyright © Dominic Robinson, 1998.
Check out
Pioneer 's Web site.
[Up to the top of this page]
Amazon.co.uk Widgets
DVDs reviewed by the editor are watched on a Panasonic TXW32R4 32" widescreen TV
connected to either a Creative Dxr2 DVD-ROM player or Microsoft Xbox and
played through a Sony STR-DB930 amplifier.
PC games reviewed by the editor are on:
Since Nov 2005: Intel Pentium D 830 3.0Ghz, 1Gb RAM, 128Mb nVidia GeForce 6700XL, Windows XP
Since Aug 2003: Intel Pentium 4 2.66Ghz, 512Mb RAM, 128Mb GeForce4 MX440 graphics, Windows XP
Since May 2003: Intel Pentium 4 2.6Ghz, 512Mb RAM, 128Mb ATI Radeon 9600TX graphics, Windows XP
Since Jun 2002: Intel Pentium III 600Mhz, 384Mb RAM, Windows 98 SE, 64Mb ATI Radeon 8500LE
Since May 2000: Intel Pentium III 600Mhz, 384Mb RAM, Windows 98 SE, Voodoo 3 3000 AGP