DVDfever.co.uk - Charts, News and Reviews of Blu-rays, DVDs, Games, CDs, Hardware, Laserdiscs, Cinema Films & more
DVDfever.co.uk - Charts, News and Reviews of DVDs, Games, Hardware, Laserdiscs, Cinema Films & more

This Week's Highlights
The King's Speech
Thor 3D
Crysis 2
Music chart
analysis w/e 14.5.11
New Blu-ray &
DVDs out 9.5.11
David Tennant
@ DVDfever Youtube

Last updated
May 11 2011

Xbox Gamertag:
DVDfever co uk

Why films on TV
in their original
widescreen ratio
is good for you

News & Views
News Archive
Announcements
All About Us
Email Dom
Write 4 DVDfever
Competitions
Music Charts
Music Chart Archive
Games Chart Archive
Cinema Chart Archive
Cinema Releases
Cinema Reviews
Press Releases
TV Issues

Frank Sidebottom's World Wide Shed

R2 DVD Reviews
Blu-ray Reviews
HD-DVD Reviews
R1 DVD Reviews
R3-6 DVD Reviews
DVD List
Xbox 360 Reviews
CD Reviews
Audiobook Reviews
PS2 Reviews
PSP Reviews
Xbox Reviews
Gamecube Revs
GBA Reviews
PC Reviews
Hardware Revs
Concert Reviews
Video Reviews
Comedy Reviews
Book Reviews
Screenplay Reviews
Movie Downloads
Interviews
TV Shows
PSX Reviews
N64 Reviews
Dreamcast Revs
Laserdisc Revs
Short Stories
DVDs In Brief

Right To Reply
Why Widescreen?
DVD Links
Music Links
WS Video List
WS PAL LD List

Me and my
Aortic Valve!

Latest News ...... DVD Reviews ...... Blu-ray Reviews ...... Xbox 360 Reviews ...... PSP Reviews ...... CD Reviews

Jason Maloney reviews

The Insider

Distributed by

Warner Bros.

    Cover
  • Cert:
  • Cat.no: D 034682
  • Running time: 151 minutes
  • Year: 1999
  • Pressing: 2000
  • Region(s): 2, PAL
  • Chapters: 30 plus extras
  • Sound: Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Languages: English, Italian
  • Subtitles: English (and hearing-impaired), Arabic, Italian, Polish
  • Widescreen: 2.35:1
  • 16:9-Enhanced: Yes
  • Macrovision: Yes
  • Disc Format: DVD 9
  • Price: £19.99
  • Extras: Featurette

    Director:

      Michael Mann

    Cast:

      Lowell Bergman: Al Pacino
      Jeffrey Wigand: Russell Crowe
      Mike Wallace: Christopher Plummer
      Don Hewitt: Philip Baker Hall
      Liane Wigand: Diane Venora
      Sharon Tiller: Lindsay Crouse
      Eric Kluster: Stephen Tobolowsky
      Debbie De Luca: Debi Mazar
      Richard Scruggs: Colm Feore
      Helen Caperelli: Gina Gershon
      John Scanlon: Rip Torn
      Thomas Sanderfur: Michael Gambon


The Insider centres on the story of Jeffrey Wigand (Crowe), and the developments arising from his sudden departure from a major US tobacco firm. Wigand claims he knows the truth behind nicotine addiction, and his employers want him silenced.

After a largely superfluous prologue that really only serves to establish the stylistic nature of the film as a whole, the tale begins. Crowe takes centre-stage for the most part, with Pacino's doggedly determined CBS news correspondant Lowell Bergman never too far behind. The dialogue is superb, the focus of the film during these scenes clear and compelling.

We're taken on a long and involved journey, shown a world of high-risk decisions on morality and ethics that tug at the conscience of each main character. Every minute aspect and nail-biting moment of tension and paranoia is magnified and lingered upon, with the assured excellence Mann has made his trademark.

During most of the opening 90 minutes, the camera lens is seldom more than 6 inches away from Crowe's visage, betraying all the tension and turmoil his whistle-blowing employee is going through. Disorientating first-person camera work switches from character to character - blurring, spinning and jumping - creating an uneasy tone that unsettles in the way it was clearly intended to.

Mann wove together a multi-level storyline quite maginificently in Heat, but here he doesn't quite pull it off. The formula is again based on assembling a huge cast of genuine talent, but most of them have only peripheral roles. This is Crowe's and Pacino's movie. The deeper the plot delves into its chosen can of worms the more any clarity is lost.


Perhaps it is deliberate, the manner in which The Insider decides to switch its attention from Crowe's dilemma to concentrate on Pacino and the subsequent corporate meddling of a different kind that arises from the case. It mirrors the way Crowe - having placed his existence on the line to give Pacino the story he wants - is left high and dry once the shit has hit the fan. It is probably not wholly coincidental that the film opens and closes with Pacino, not Crowe....although it is still the latter who etches himself deepest into the very heart of The Insider.

For his first directorial outing since the near-perfect Heat in late 1995, Michael Mann took an article from Vanity Fair magazine entitled "The Man Who Knew Too Much" and used the true story as the basis of this slightly dramatised tale of corporate cover-ups and deception in the tobacco industry.

Dramatised. That word again. Is it true or is it all made up? No, it's dramatised. It's both and it's neither. In some cases, alterations of fact and inventions of events and people that never took place and who never existed has little negligible effect on the finished article. The Insider, on the other hand, rests much of its dramatic and emotional power on something which - come the final credits - apparently differs from the actual reality.


Now, call me stupid, but taking 2-and-a-half hours to tell a very detailed and intense story (keeping all names intact) only to declare come the closing reel words to the effect of "oh, it didn't really turn out like this....the opposite happened " seems pointless, and detracts from what is an otherwise masterful movie. "Huh?", you may find yourself saying, when it's over. "Why?", even.

It looks stunning however, dominated by Mann's beloved blues and greys, and sounds equally marvellous. The score plays an integral part in proceedings, ranging from ambient noodlings to full-blown nerve jangling flourishes, while remaining comprehensively un-Hollywood in its style.

The main problem with the sound is the muted nature of the dialogue, which seems to have been buried just a little too deep in the audio mix. Turning the volume up to almost double the norm only improves things slightly.

An unsual featurette has the leading actors talking "in character" - a neat idea and the only bonus material on the disc. Buena Vista have improved in the extras department of late, but this is more in keeping with earlier titles than the recent likes of End of Days, The Sixth Sense or The Talented Mr Ripley.


Given its pedigree and universal acclaim, The Insider is something of a disappointment. Michael Gambon's dreadful cod-Texan drawl is another blemish - though his cameo is thankfully as brief as his accent is unconvincing. Nevertheless, it would be amiss to claim that The Insider fails to provide top-quality viewing for its entire 150 minutes. This is still a superior film, with two of the finest central performances to be seen this year, or any other year.

FILM CONTENT
PICTURE QUALITY
SOUND QUALITY
EXTRAS



OVERALL

Review copyright © Jason Maloney, 2000.

E-mail Jason Maloney

Check out Jason's homepage: The Slipstream.

[Up to the top of this page]

DVDfever.co.uk - Est. February 25th 2000

As of April 2009, Blu-rays and DVDs reviewed by the editor are watched on a Panasonic TH-37PX80B 37" Plasma TV with a Sony BDP-1500 Blu-ray player and played through a Yamaha DSP-AX820 amplifier.

PC games reviewed by the editor are on:

  • Since Jan 2011: Intel Quad Core Dell XPS 8100, i7 CPU 860 @ 2.80Ghz, 8Gb RAM, nVidia GeForce GTS 240, Windows 7
  • Since Nov 2005: Intel Pentium D 830 3.0Ghz, 1Gb RAM, 128Mb nVidia GeForce 6700XL, Windows XP
  • Since Aug 2003: Intel Pentium 4 2.66Ghz, 512Mb RAM, 128Mb GeForce4 MX440 graphics, Windows XP
  • Since May 2003: Intel Pentium 4 2.6Ghz, 512Mb RAM, 128Mb ATI Radeon 9600TX graphics, Windows XP
  • Since Jun 2002: Intel Pentium III 600Mhz, 384Mb RAM, Windows 98 SE, 64Mb ATI Radeon 8500LE
  • Since May 2000: Intel Pentium III 600Mhz, 384Mb RAM, Windows 98 SE, Voodoo 3 3000 AGP