DVDfever.co.uk - Doctor Who Series 5 Episode 8 review by Dan OwenDVDfever.co.uk - Charts, News and Reviews of Blu-rays, DVDs, Games, CDs, Hardware, Laserdiscs, Cinema Films & more
Series 5 Vol.1 Blu-ray:
Series 5 Vol.1 DVD:
2009 Specials (Blu-ray):
Director:
Ashley Way
Screenplay:
Chris Chibnall
Cast:
The Doctor: Matt Smith
Amy Pond: Karen Gillan
Rory: Arthur Darvill
Alaya: Neve McIntosh
Nasreen: Meera Syal
Tony: Robert Pugh
Ambrose: Nia Roberts
Elliot: Samuel Davies
Mo: Alun Raglan
Expect spoilers
The great thing about two-parters is that they give a story the chance to breathe and embed itself emotionally; the bad thing is that some stories don't justify the extra allotted time. "The Hungry Earth" was basically an hour of setup for what looks like a more exciting second-half next week (if the sometimes misleading trail is to be believed), and while there were certainly some strong moments and boredom never took hold, it wasn't anything special.
The Doctor (Matt Smith), Amy (Karen Gillan) and Rory (Arthur Darvil) arrived in a Welsh village circa 2020; an accidental detour on the way to Rio (huh?), but one The Doctor became more excited by after spotting mysterious clumps of blue grass growing in a graveyard, and an interesting "mining thingy" in the distance. Rory was distracted by a boy called Elliot (Samuel Davies) and his mum Ambrose's (Nia Roberts) tale of corpses going missing from graves; leaving The Doctor and Amy to meet seasoned drillers Nasreen (Meera Syal) and Tony (Robert Pugh), who appear to have angered subterranean aliens (the Silurians) with their deep boring. Later, with Amy dragged down a hole and a high-tech force-field activated to contain the village above, The Doctor realized he only has eight-minutes before the disturbed underground inhabitants broke through to the surface.
"The Hungry Earth" wasn't terrible, just underwhelming given the potential of the story, although admittedly it's only half-fulfilled at this point. None of the guest-stars made a good impression -- particularly Syal, who was implausible in every respect, and became a temporary companion I'd happily watch disappear into a sinkhole. More fun was The Doctor's interaction with young Elliot, mainly because children's wide-eyed wonder of The Doctor is always very charming and justified compared to how adult companions behave around him. For kids he's the cool uncle, the mad teacher, or the crazy granddad. I also liked the moment when The Doctor's lack of parental experience was highlighted, when he absentmindedly allowed Elliot to wander off into danger because he was distracted with something else.
Anyway, all the characters suffered this week beyond The Doctor (and even he was written with more of a David Tennant flair, no?) The new faces for the episode were simply along for the ride, there to ask The Doctor questions on behalf of the audience -- which also felt unnecessary because it was obvious what was going on within the first 10-minutes. Amy was marginalized because of her early capture by the reptilian Silurians (but God bless her miniskirt anyway) and Rory didn't get much to do this week, despite early promise when he was mistaken as an expert.
Fortunately, Matt Smith's befuddled charms helped enormously to compensate for a storyline that felt very predictable and never really developed a sense of reality. The world's deepest bore hole in a sleepy Welsh mining village, manned by a few people? Really? The only truly interesting wrinkle to the script was knowing the Silurians were once the dominant species on Earth, so still believe they have ownership of the planet. Hopefully that will be developed into a compelling argument for part 2, "Cold Blood".
Overall, "The Hungry Planet" was middle-of-the-road entertainment with enjoyable moments, but it definitely felt like an episode that demands you watch the conclusion before passing final judgement.
Asides:
There was a very intriguing moment with The Doctor spotting future versions of Amy and Rory through some binoculars early in the episode before the adventure had really started; a scene that reminded me of something from time-loop movies like Timecrimes or Triangle. It would be nice if that got some pay-off (in part 2, or later in the season), as I'm not sure what its relevance was, beyond assuring Amy and Rory that their marriage stands a chance of surviving 10 years at least.
The scenery. Some gorgeous locations, especially in HD. I'm enjoying series 5's quaint rural feel on Earth, away from Russell T. Davies urban estates.
Good makeup for the Silurians, if unoriginal in design. The alien character of Alaya was also nicely performed, particularly in her "interrogation scene" with The Doctor.
A great moment between The Doctor and Amy when he failed to prevent her being sucked down into the ground.
Is anyone else frustrated that so many episodes remind you of recent episodes in Who's history? "The Impossible Planet" (often an inspiration for other episodes, it seems) came to mind because of its own subterranean dangers.
The Silurians made their debut in the 1970 adventure starring the Third Doctor (Jon Pertwee), and their cousins the Sea Devils aappeared sometime later. They also appeared in the Fifth Doctor (Peter Davison) story "Warriors Of The Deep" back in 1984.
As of April 2009, Blu-rays and DVDs reviewed by the editor are watched on a Panasonic TH-37PX80B
37" Plasma TV with a Sony BDP-1500 Blu-ray player and played through a Yamaha DSP-AX820 amplifier.
PC games reviewed by the editor are on:
Since Jan 2011: Intel Quad Core Dell XPS 8100, i7 CPU 860 @ 2.80Ghz, 8Gb RAM, nVidia GeForce GTS 240, Windows 7
Since Nov 2005: Intel Pentium D 830 3.0Ghz, 1Gb RAM, 128Mb nVidia GeForce 6700XL, Windows XP
Since Aug 2003: Intel Pentium 4 2.66Ghz, 512Mb RAM, 128Mb GeForce4 MX440 graphics, Windows XP
Since May 2003: Intel Pentium 4 2.6Ghz, 512Mb RAM, 128Mb ATI Radeon 9600TX graphics, Windows XP
Since Jun 2002: Intel Pentium III 600Mhz, 384Mb RAM, Windows 98 SE, 64Mb ATI Radeon 8500LE
Since May 2000: Intel Pentium III 600Mhz, 384Mb RAM, Windows 98 SE, Voodoo 3 3000 AGP
Series 5 Vol.1 Blu-ray:
